How to Price Doll Restoration Based on Color-Matching Complexity

The Pricing Problem

Doll restoration pricing typically accounts for structural repair, cleaning, and painting. But within "painting," the time required varies enormously depending on color-matching complexity. A simple touch-up on well-preserved paint might need one kiln firing. A full face restoration on a heavily degraded doll with multiple previous restorations could need 15+ firings.

If you price both the same, you lose money on complex jobs and overprice simple ones.

Complexity Factors

Factor 1: How much original paint survives?

• 80%+ surviving: Minor touch-up. Low complexity.
• 40-80% surviving: Moderate in-painting. Medium complexity.
• Under 40% surviving: Extensive restoration. High complexity.
• Near zero: Full recreation. Highest complexity — you are matching to manufacturer references, not to the specific doll.

Factor 2: How many colors need matching?

• Cheek blush only: One color system.
• Blush + lips: Two systems, needing to harmonize.
• Blush + lips + eyebrows: Three systems.
• Full face including eyes: Four or more systems — each needing to harmonize with every other.

Factor 3: How degraded is the surviving paint?

• Mildly faded: Clear reference for matching. Lower difficulty.
• Heavily faded: Ambiguous reference. Requires degradation analysis to determine original.
• Multiple previous restorations: Must untangle layers before matching.

Factor 4: How demanding is the client?

• Museum or institutional: May require documentation, spectral analysis, reversibility.
• Dealer: Usually wants fast, good-enough restoration for resale.
• Private collector: Variable — some want museum-grade, some want affordable.

A Pricing Framework

Tier 1: Touch-up ($150-400)

• One or two small areas needing color matching
• Original paint well-preserved as reference
• 1-2 kiln firings expected
• 2-4 hours total

Tier 2: Moderate restoration ($400-1,200)

• Multiple areas needing matching
• Original paint moderately degraded
• 3-6 kiln firings expected
• 8-20 hours total

Tier 3: Extensive restoration ($1,200-3,500)

• Major paint loss requiring matching to manufacturer references
• Possible previous restoration removal
• 8-15 kiln firings expected
• 25-60 hours total

Tier 4: Museum-grade full restoration ($3,500-10,000+)

• Near-complete paint loss or extensive previous restoration
• Requires analytical identification of original pigments
• Full documentation package
• 15+ kiln firings possible
• 60+ hours total

Communicating Value

Clients who understand the complexity of color matching are more willing to pay appropriately. Brief explanations help:

• "Each color requires separate kiln firings to test and apply — and each firing takes several hours"
• "The faded original paint has shifted in ways that require careful analysis to match accurately"
• "Getting the color wrong risks damage when removing and reapplying"

How Better Tools Affect Pricing

Degradation modeling tools reduce complexity by:

• Providing better first-attempt accuracy (fewer kiln cycles)
• Making complex projects more predictable
• Reducing the risk premium you need to build into quotes

This lets you offer competitive pricing on complex jobs while maintaining your margin — or complete the same tier of work in less time, increasing throughput.

Want to reduce color-matching complexity and improve your pricing accuracy? Join the PigmentBoard waitlist.